Discussion:
(long) A review of "Fraudcast News (FABF18)"
(too old to reply)
Benjamin Robinson
2004-05-24 05:30:03 UTC
Permalink
[The long of it]

If at first you don't succeed, try again. A trite phrase, perhaps,
but a true one. Last week's "Bart-Mangled Banner (FABF17)" aimed at
being sharp social satire, but overly exaggerated humor deflected
attention from its central point. (The pseudonymous Lord Jubjub was
more concise than I: He said it was, "over the top.") "Fraudcast
News" offered another political topic, and a chance of redemption.
This time, the writers turned the wacky knob back a bit, to our
benefit.

The cause celebre this time is the consolidation trend in mass media,
where formerly independent news outlets get bound up into giant
monolithic media empires. Critics contend this channels too much
power into the hands of an elite few, who might bend the news to suit
their hidden agendas. If they weren't thinking of Monty Burns as an
example before, they will after watching tonight's show. The old man
is presumed to have been killed when a stone formation in one of
Springfield's parks collapses, burying him under tons of stones. The
writers aren't dumb enough to kill off such an important character, of
course, so Burns survives to be offended by an unflattering eulogy on
the evening news. Remember the old joke about the rich man who buys a
hotel just so he can fire a surly desk clerk? Burns does something
similar: He buys up all of Springfield's news outlets and immediately
turns them into vehicles of self-glorification.

The story becomes more interesting when Lisa starts up her own paper
to publish an elegy about the very same formation that "killed" Burns.
(It seems to me that Lisa would want to start a literary journal
instead, but that's being nit-picky.) After Burns's media coup, hers
is the last independent media voice in the town and, needless to say,
she and Burns clash. There is some exaggeration involved -- an eight-
year-old, even a plucky one like Lisa, isn't going to seriously
threaten Burns and his well-funded media machine -- but it's more
reasonable tonight. We don't see any re-education camps, and the
whole town doesn't rush to take sides. Instead, "Fraudcast News" is a
straightforward David-and-Goliath story, taking place in just one
town. It's much easier to suspend disbelief.

The writers might have helped themselves with their choice of subject
matter, too. Media ownership is a more obscure topic than post-9/11
civil rights, so the audience brings fewer preconceptions to the show.
Also, no matter where they stand in the political spectrum, people
think that the media is secretly or overtly aligned against their
point of view. It's easy to relate to put-upon Lisa and her "Red
Dress Press."

"Fraudcast" doesn't have any really knock-it-out-of-the-park humor,
but the jokes are pretty good, on average. Burns uses his control of
Itchy & Scratchy studios to create a terrific pro-nuclear propaganda
film. Now that I think of it, I wish there was more time to show
Burns seeding the media with other messages supporting his causes,
instead of cramming most of them into this one short. Later, Homer
ends a tribute to his daughter with, "When I grow up, I want to be
just like her. Except still a dude." Fans of headlines get a feast
tonight, what with the war of words between Burns and Lisa. I also
liked Bart's second political cartoon, which shows Burns tying a dog
(labeled "Free Speech") to a railroad track, and Smithers as a
locomotive bearing down on them.

Still, the writing highlight wasn't a joke at all, but rather Lisa's
poem. It's a pretty elegy to Springfield's Old Geezer mountain. One
nice touch is that the poem wasn't perfect. Lisa still has a mannered
poetic style, salting her language with a lot of archaic "thees" and
"arts." She'll probably grow out of that, but for now she writes like
a bright eight-year-old, instead of a thirty-eight-year-old
professional screenwriter. Nice touch.

The writers normally pick one of the better episodes to serve as a
season finale, and they've done so again. "Fraudcast News" has a
message about the importance of an independent media, so it's a good
thing the writers trust the audience to get the point without
outrageous humor. If you're reading this right now, then I guess the
Burns media machine agrees. And, as you know, that dashing Mr. Burns
is right about everything.

[The short of it]

Another political satire, but this time the writers wisely turn down
the "wacky humor" knob. There's some exaggeration in the David-vs.-
Goliath tale, but not so much that we can't suspend disbelief. The
writers also help themselves with more bipartisan subject matter, as
both conservatives and liberals think the media conspires against
them. The jokes are good on average, and headline fans get a feast
tonight. Lisa's poem is terrific: Well-written, but not *too* well
for a little girl. As usual, the show delivers a good season finale,
even if it is a little harsh on that kind-hearted philanthropist, C.
Montgomery Burns. (B+)

[DYN]

... the production code turns out to be FABF18, after all?
... during the dedication ceremonies, you can see Homer climbing Old
Geezer mountain?
... the portrait of the Burns-like female ancestor, visible over
Burns's shoulder when he returns to his mansion?
... Lisa must have revised her poem before publishing it, since it
refers to the Old Geezer's collapse?
... the bottle of Duff in Barney's paper-carrying bag?

[References]

"Broadcast News" (movie)
- spoofed in title
(fittingly, the movie was a James L. Brooks production)

Old Man of the Mountain (tourist spot)
- rock feature in New Hampshire that resembles a bearded man in
profile; Springfield's Old Geezer is very similar [See
"Personal Comments & Observations" for more]

Blood, Sweat & Tears (band)
- two of the three members appear at the Old Geezer dedication

Quiznos (sub sandwich chain)
- had a commercial showing a man nursing from a wolf, the way
Burns nurses from a mole

Grit (newspaper)
- offers kids a chance to "win swell prizes" by selling
subscriptions

"Superman" (comic book)
- Frink yells, "Great Glavin's Ghost," like the editor of the
Daily Planet and his "Great Caesar's Ghost" catchphrase

"What's New, Pussycat?" (song)
- title of Itchy & Scratchy cartoon a spoof

the New York Post (newspaper)
- when the government turned down financial assistance to New York
City, the Post ran a headline reading, "DC to New York: Drop
Dead"

the Jayson Blair affair
- Milhouse admits that he just made up his stories from abroad

The PennySaver (newspaper)
- Lenny publishes The LennySaver

~"The Truth About Charlie" (movie)
- Lenny's headline, "The Truth About Carl," sounds similar

[Previous Episode References]

[1F03], [CABF18] T-Bird from 1964-66 seen
[9F15], [1F18] Deal cemented with, "Done, and done!"
[9F15] Burns-like vulture seen
[7F22] Burns and Smithers go on a shopping spree

[FFF]

Smithers's chest tattoo:

BOSS
[Smithers] OF MY [Burns]
HEART

Lisa's first edition:

The
Red Dress Press
-----------------
[Lisa]
OUR EDITOR

Lisa's poem:

ELEGY FOR GEEZER ROCK
By Lisa Simpson

Postcard image, thing to see,
To think of Springfield is to think of th
What thoughts be-pass a'hind thy mi
Why sky art blue, why tree art gree
And what, pray tell, did thine eyes
old friend, they gazed

[Want the whole thing? I transcribed it below.]

TV Studio:

+----------------+
|+--------------+|
|| /-\ ||
|| CHANNEL |6| ||
|| \-/ ||
|+--------------+|
|STILL IN ENGLISH|
+----------------+

Burns later adds:

A Division of Burns Media [logo]

Shopper's new headline:

BELOVED HERO CHEATS DEATH

Itchy & Scratchy title card:

ITCHY & SCRATCHY
in
what's
nuked,
pussycat?

Burns's magazine:

BURNS
WEEKLY

[Burns]

"It's Too Late"

Second "Red Dress Press" headline:

The
Red Dress Press
-----------------
LISA TO BURNS:
'DROP DEAD'

RALPH WIGGUM'S [Ralph's]
OSCAR PICS [ pic ]

The goons force Homer into:

RATTLESNAKE
SANCTUARY

Chicago Tribune front page:

Chicago Tribune
---------------
[Ralph]
Ralphings
----------
I Can Go
On The Bus

Skinner's mimeographed ad:

CHAIR FOR SALE:
FIVE DOLLARS O.B.O.

+-+
|_|
/_/|
| |

GREAT FOR SITTING

Third "Red Dress Press" headline:

The
Red Dress Press
-----------------
NYAH, NYAH
WE'RE BACK
Lisa Rules, Burns Drools

"Springfield Shopper" headline:

Springfield Shopper
---------------------
DAILY NEWS 50¢
---------------------
LISA'S A TOTAL WACKO,
IMPLIES FATHER
[ Homer ]
[speaking ]
[into lamp]

Second "Springfield Shopper" headline:

Springfield Shopper
---------------------
DAILY NEWS 50¢
---------------------
LISA LOVES
MILHOUSE
[Lisa] [Milhouse]

Fourth "Red Dress Press" headline:

The
Red Dress Press
-----------------
FINAL
'I GIVE UP'
EDITION

"The Homer Press" headline:

The HOMER Times
---------------
MY DAUGHTER,
MY HERO

The LennySaver headline:

The LennySaver
--------------
THE TRUTH
ABOUT CARL:
--------------
HE'S GREAT!
[Carl]

Patty and Selma's paper:

TWIN SPIN

Other people peddling their papers in Homer's neighborhood:

- Barney
- Nelson
- Bumblebee Man
- Lenny
- Jimbo, Dolph, and Kearney
- Disco Stu
- Professor Frink
- Groundskeeper Willie
- Patty and Selma
- an anonymous man and woman

[Personal Comments & Observations]
Musical References
Before the batteries mercifully give out, Homer listens to a bit of
"Do You Wanna Be My Lover," by the Pretenders.
Meta-Reference corner
The teen hurling himself off Geezer Rock was despondent over the
cancellation of "Futurama." (Aw, I was hoping it would escape that
fate in the "Simpsons" universe.) By remarkable coincidence,
"Futurama" was Matt Groening's other animated sitcom.

Mr. Burns and Smithers kiss up to Rupert Murdoch, who runs News
Corporation, which owns the Fox television network (and the movie
studio, and the home entertainment company, among other things).
If only he had gotten that facelift
Take a look at the change in your pocket. You might have a quarter
commemorating the Old Man of the Mountain, a rock formation in New
Hampshire that looks like a bearded man, seen in profile. If you're
like me, that quarter was your introduction to the Old Man; I never
heard of it before than. As it turns out, the quarter is now the only
way you can see this natural wonder, as the real thing collapsed just
recently, a victim of erosion. (At least, I think I did. The only
place I heard this is, of all places, "Saturday Night Live's" Weekend
Update.)
Extra! Extra! It's Car Watch!
The suicidal teen lands safely in a Ford Thunderbird, c. 1964 to 1966.

The goons' sedan is a Lincoln Town Car. The grille is more accurately
drawn when the car first pulls up to the Simpsons' wagon than it is in
the front-end shot that immediately follows.

It technically isn't a car, but the vehicle that finally forces Homer
off the road is a Kamen Industries Segway. Homer must have been
driving very slowly at this point, since the top speed of a Segway is
about 12 miles an hour. (Of course, the goons might have had a
souped-up version.)
Name Dropping
Larry Flynt -- Publisher of "Hustler," a notorious girlie magazine.
Homer mentions the woman who wheels Flynt around. The real-life Flynt
is a wheelchair user; a would-be assassin's bullet pierced his spine.
I think the woman is his wife, Althea.
CNNBCBS: A Division of ABC
The premise of tonight's episode was likely inspired by real-life
fighting over new FCC regulations. (For readers outside the United
States: The FCC is the federal agency that sets rules for broadcast
media such as television and radio.) Until recently, the FCC forbade
any one person or company to own more than 35% of all the TV and radio
stations nationally, or to own all the stations in one market. There
were restrictions on owning a TV station, radio station, and newspaper
in one area, too. This was before the age of media consolidation.
Large conglomerates like, say, Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation
wanted the FCC wanted to relax these rules so they could expand their
empires. The FCC did so, and met with sharp criticism, mainly from
the press. Their argument was that lack of diversity would lead to
total political control; their vision of the future strongly resembled
the post-Burns world shown tonight. The moguls replied that with new
media like the internet, it would be impossible to control even a
majority of the media, let alone all of it. These arguments ignored
the fact that (a) no internet news source has anywhere near the
influence of a major newspaper or television network, and (b) there
was no regulation from stopping conglomerates from owning internet
content providers, as well. In any case, Congress sided with the
public, putting the new FCC regulations on hold for now.
Musical References
Just kidding -- Homer was listening to the Spice Girls, making him one
of the last people on Earth to do so voluntarily.
Lisa's Poetry Corner
I figured someone would ask for Lisa's poem, so here it is. Customer
service is our #1 goal!

Elegy for Geezer Rock
By Lisa Simpson

Postcard image, thing to see,
To Think of Springfield is to think of thee.
What thoughts be-pass a'hind thy mien?
Why sky art blue, why trees art green?
And what, pray tell, did thine eyes see?
Perchance, old friend, they gazed at me.

Brought low by Nature's oafish hand
Thou crushed our reviewing stand.
And twixt thy stones glimpsed I the truth:

All things must pass, thy face, thy youth.
--
Benjamin Robinson ***@freenet.tlh.fl.us
This message may or may not contain sarcastic content; your burden to decide
"I'm naked, clueless, and f-e-e-e-ling good!" -- Ratbert
Michael Black
2004-05-24 05:51:07 UTC
Permalink
Post by Benjamin Robinson
"What's New, Pussycat?" (song)
- title of Itchy & Scratchy cartoon a spoof
While the song is likely best known, surely this is a reference
to "What's New, Pussycat?" (movie).

It came out in 1965, starring Peter Sellers, and the rest of the cast
included Woody Allen, in one of his few roles that were not in his
own films. Tom Jones is listed in the credits at IMDB, so the song
must appear in the film, but I don't know if it was done specifically
for the film.

Michael
A***@zimage.com
2004-05-24 06:17:32 UTC
Permalink
Ironic from a previous episode: "I could crush him like an ant. But it
would be too easy. No, revenge is a dish best served cold. I'll bide
my time until... Oh, what the hell, I'll just crush him like an ant."
--Mr. Burns, The Simpsons ("Blood Feud" Episode 7F22)

It looks like Mr. Burns couldn't do it on a tiny insect tonight! ;)
--
"Ants. There's a size for every picnic, a colour for every occasion,
and a bite to let you know that they are there. Apart from the bite,
that could describe a Basenji pretty well." --Len Reddie
/\___/\
/ /\ /\ \ Phillip Pi (Ant) @ The Ant Farm: http://antfarm.ma.cx
| |o o| | E-mail: ***@earthlink.netANT or ***@zimage.com
\ _ / Be sure you removed ANT from e-mail address if you get
( ) a returned e-mail.
Yarn Spinner
2004-05-24 10:52:30 UTC
Permalink
There was another Superman ref.
Lisa: Don't call me Chief!


Jesse McCann, New York Times Bestsellers List Children's Author
*What I'm writing now:
SIMPSONS EPISODE GUIDE #4 (seasons 13 and 14)
<A href="http://hometown.aol.com/jleon2001/myhomepage/index.html">Resume</A>
synecdoche
2004-05-24 11:39:19 UTC
Permalink
Post by Benjamin Robinson
Before the batteries mercifully give out, Homer listens to a bit of
"Do You Wanna Be My Lover," by the Pretenders.
Er, that was "Wannabe" by The Spice Girls, as ashamed as I am to admit
that I know that.

dave
Michael Black
2004-05-24 15:48:15 UTC
Permalink
Post by synecdoche
Post by Benjamin Robinson
Before the batteries mercifully give out, Homer listens to a bit of
"Do You Wanna Be My Lover," by the Pretenders.
Er, that was "Wannabe" by The Spice Girls, as ashamed as I am to admit
that I know that.
dave
You missed the bit way later in the post, where he references that
bit and says he knows it's a Spice Girls song.

Clearly, the reference to The Pretenders was a reference to the error
here last week where a Blondie song was credited to The Pretenders.

Michael
Ryan W. Mead
2004-05-24 18:55:17 UTC
Permalink
Post by synecdoche
Post by Benjamin Robinson
Before the batteries mercifully give out, Homer listens to a bit of
"Do You Wanna Be My Lover," by the Pretenders.
Er, that was "Wannabe" by The Spice Girls, as ashamed as I am to admit
that I know that.
dave
I was going to correct Ben on the title of the song, but I see you
already did that. As for the artist, Mr. Robinson later commented:

"Just kidding -- Homer was listening to the Spice Girls, making him
one
of the last people on Earth to do so voluntarily."

Of course, he may have been right on both accounts-the Spice Girls
were pretty much a group of five girls *pretending* to be the next big
thing in music. (joke, sad attempt at)

-R.
Ryan W. Mead
2004-05-24 19:01:08 UTC
Permalink
Post by Benjamin Robinson
- when the government turned down financial assistance to New York
City, the Post ran a headline reading, "DC to New York: Drop
Dead"
I don't know when this happened, but there was a very famous Daily
News headline before this one: "Ford to City: Drop Dead."
Post by Benjamin Robinson
If only he had gotten that facelift
Take a look at the change in your pocket. You might have a quarter
commemorating the Old Man of the Mountain, a rock formation in New
Hampshire that looks like a bearded man, seen in profile. If you're
like me, that quarter was your introduction to the Old Man; I never
heard of it before than. As it turns out, the quarter is now the only
way you can see this natural wonder, as the real thing collapsed just
recently, a victim of erosion. (At least, I think I did. The only
place I heard this is, of all places, "Saturday Night Live's" Weekend
Update.)
Tina and Jimmy usually tell the real story before giving a punchline,
and this case is no exception. The Old Man of the Mountain, New
Hampshire's favorite son! He appears on their license plates and state
route markers, and was the subject of some famous dead author's "The
Great Stone Face." Then, he died. Erosion was the cause. They hope to
bring him back again someday by getting rid of more rock to make
another face.
Benjamin Robinson
2004-05-26 04:22:59 UTC
Permalink
In alt.tv.simpsons, on the "Re: (long) A review of "Fraudcast News
Post by Ryan W. Mead
I don't know when this happened, but there was a very famous Daily
News headline before this one: "Ford to City: Drop Dead."
Actually, that's what I was trying to remember. The headline came out when
I was in grade school, so obviously I didn't remember it exactly.
Post by Ryan W. Mead
They hope to
bring him [the Old Man of the Mountain] back again someday by getting rid
of more rock to make another face.
Wouldn't that defeat the purpose? I thought the appeal of the Old Man was
that it was a completely natural phenomenon.
--
Benjamin Robinson ***@freenet.tlh.fl.us
This message may or may not contain sarcastic content; your burden to decide
"I'm naked, clueless, and f-e-e-e-ling good!" -- Ratbert
Michael Black
2004-05-26 05:21:49 UTC
Permalink
Post by Benjamin Robinson
In alt.tv.simpsons, on the "Re: (long) A review of "Fraudcast News
Post by Ryan W. Mead
I don't know when this happened, but there was a very famous Daily
News headline before this one: "Ford to City: Drop Dead."
Actually, that's what I was trying to remember. The headline came out when
I was in grade school, so obviously I didn't remember it exactly.
Post by Ryan W. Mead
They hope to
bring him [the Old Man of the Mountain] back again someday by getting rid
of more rock to make another face.
Wouldn't that defeat the purpose? I thought the appeal of the Old Man was
that it was a completely natural phenomenon.
Yes. But of course, long after The Old Man of the Mountain came
into being, there came along those upstart faces on Mount Rushmore, and
then that upstart Crazy Horse statue (under construction for over fifty
years) nearby.

New Hampshire now has a problem. They've lost The Old Man of the Mountain
(I don't know if it was such a major tourist attraction that people went
to the state especially for it, but obviously it was something to see
if you were there), while other places have such things because they
made them. In order to keep up, New Hampshire may not have any choice.
Michael
Nathan
2004-05-27 05:32:46 UTC
Permalink
Post by Benjamin Robinson
Blood, Sweat & Tears (band)
- two of the three members appear at the Old Geezer dedication
BS&T had a full horn section, so I'm sure there were a lot more than three
members. And I'm also pretty sure, they didn't actually go by "Blood,"
"Sweat," and "Tears." <g>
--
Brick is red, and Hitler's dead,
Nathan
***@tmbg.org
http://vovat.blogspot.com/

Loading...